Fool's errand: Betting MLB without considering these factors

By Jeff Fogle  ( 

March 31, 2019 04:46 PM

Fitting that, on April Fool’s Day, VSiN is going to talk about the challenges of handicapping Major League Baseball. Today’s managers won’t stop fooling around with their starting rotations!

The essence of picking baseball winners used to be very simple. How is each starting pitcher likely to perform against the opposing offense? If one had a clear edge over the other, bet him at affordable (or underdog) prices. If both were in great shape, bet the Under. If both were likely to get hit, bet the Over. 

Now, the starting pitcher may get yanked just as he starts to get in trouble, even if it’s only the third of fourth inning. Sometimes, the starting pitcher isn’t even a starting pitcher! Tampa Bay, in particular, had great success last season with “openers” who would throw a couple of innings before handing off to the next guy.

Success gets copied. Because this successful strategy was cheap, effective, and helpful in keeping the entire bullpen active and sharp, more and more teams will at least experiment with the approach. 

How should sports bettors deal with this developing situation? 

Some ideas…

  • Monitor each manager’s rotation preferences through April until you get a full sense of how long starters are likely to last, and how effective mid-game relievers will be.
  • Remember that differences in offenses are often what separate the best teams from the worst. Maybe you were spending too much time studying starting pitchers in the past anyway. Be sure you know normal run-scoring expectations for each MLB offense.
  • Zoom in your focus on home run dynamics. Which starters and mid-game relievers are most likely to allow dingers? Which offenses are most consistent about going deep? Because pitching is becoming “throw as hard as you can, as long as you can,” run production is trending toward “how far can you hit high heat?” Maybe you’ll find a team or pitcher strength or weakness before the rest of the market.
  • VSiN always encourages bettors to be aware of ballpark effects. It’s not hard to do a web search for details on stadium tendencies. ESPN’s website has data from the past several seasons. While the market is aware of park effects, it can underestimate the impact of “cocktails” containing ingredients that mix together well (a consistent home run offense facing a home-run prone pitcher in a great home run park, or a fly ball pitcher facing a weaker offense in a spacious stadium).

Don’t let baseball make you feel foolish. Work smart so you can bet smart!



back to news

FREE Email Sign-Up

Get the latest sports betting news & VSiN programming updates with this free daily email from VSiN, The Sports Betting Network.


View All
  • Zach_LaVine

    Tuley's Takes Today: Tuesday recaps, Circa Quarter prizes, Wednesday best bet (12/8)

    “You can’t win ‘em all.” If you were to watch games with me in the Tuley’s Takes home office or in one of the sportsbooks...
  • bama

    Early CFP Semifinals Sharp Report

    Today bettors have a loaded Wednesday slate to choose from including 13 NBA games, 4 NHL games and 50 College Basketball games. For an updated breakdown...
  • USATSI_17214623

    Peterson: Best bet for Wyoming vs. Arizona

    The Wyoming Cowboys have started out the season with eight straight wins, but face their toughest test yet when they go to Tucson on Wednesday to face...
  • makinennfl

    Analyzing NFL QBs for betting success

    I have always been a football handicapper who puts a ton of stock into the quality of quarterback play. In my opinion, there is no more important position...
  • makinencbb

    Ten midmajors to watch

    The college basketball season has been up and running for nearly a month, and it’s a good time to start plotting for the rest of the season based...
  • makinencfb

    Who's hot, not ahead of bowls?

    With college bowl season opening Dec. 17, here’s a look at which bowl-bound teams are hot and which are not, as well as teams that have had big...
  • burkesurvivor

    Tricky week in survivor pools

    There are only five weeks left in the NFL regular season, but for those still alive in survivor pools, the light at the end of the tunnel is merely a...
  • burkecbb

    Why pace matters in college hoops

    A lot of early-season questions have been answered in college basketball. But as conference play kicks into gear, adjustments will be needed. There...
  • tuley

    Tuley's Takes on NFL Week 14

    NFL Week 13 was another roller-coaster ride here in the Tuley’s Takes home office, but as has happened many weekends this season, teasers saved...
  • hill

    NFL capsules for Week 14

    Pittsburgh Steelers at Minnesota Vikings The Pittsburgh Steelers (6-5-1 SU, 5-7 ATS) will be looking for their second win in five days when they...
  • appelbaum

    Five NFL games on wise guys' radar

    It was a mixed bag for NFL Week 13 bettors as favorites went 8-6 SU and 8-6 ATS. Dogs remain profitable for the season at 107-85-1 ATS (56 percent). ...
  • macneil

    NHL teams slip-sliding away

    The Canucks and Flyers fired their coaches over the weekend, and the Canucks took it a step further, firing their general manager as well. It’s...

VSiN Logo Plus

Free Trial

Make a risk-free bet on VSiN!


  • Afternoon subscriber-only email with highlights and best bets from the day's programs
  • Point Spread Weekly, VSiN's digital magazine on sports betting
  • 24-7 Live video stream of VSiN programs plus replays
  • Any special sport-specified betting guides we do
  • All exclusive subscriber-only stories and data on
Sign Up Now
Google Play
App Store