Colts down on their Luck after his shoulder surgery

Matt Youmans  
VSiN senior editor

July 30, 2017 06:07 AM

When a concussion sidelined Andrew Luck for a week in November, Scott Tolzien started for the Colts and passed for 205 yards and one touchdown with two interceptions in a 28-7 loss to Pittsburgh.
© USA Today Sports Images

Despite coaching and front-office shortcomings, the Indianapolis Colts have remained competitive mostly because they have an elite quarterback. Andrew Luck is a major difference-maker, and his critics who say otherwise are fools.

Oddsmakers say this: Without Luck, the Colts would be underdogs to one of the NFL’s worst teams.

Luck, still rehabbing from offseason surgery on his right shoulder, admitted Saturday that he might not be ready for Indianapolis’ regular-season opener. At several Las Vegas books, the Colts are posted as 3-point road favorites over the Los Angeles Rams on Sept. 10.

Jimmy Vaccaro, oddsmaker at the South Point sports book, took the game and the Colts’ season win total off the board amid the mystery surrounding Luck’s status.

“We have been careful with the Colts the whole time,” Vaccaro said. “I think it’s a major change without Luck. I think this thing is much worse than they are saying.”

The Colts are not saying much about Luck’s progress, and he would not even say if he’s throwing a football yet. He did say he’s throwing a tennis ball. As the team opened training camp, he would not commit to a timetable on his return to the practice field.

Vaccaro speculated Luck could miss the first month of the season and maybe more, so he took down Indianapolis’ win total, which was 8½ (under minus-115).

The Colts finished last season 8-8, third in the AFC South, and missed the playoffs. Luck finished with 31 touchdown passes and 13 interceptions. He was sacked 41 times, the second-highest total in the league.

A key factor in determining a quarterback’s value to the point spread is the quality of the backup. Behind Luck on the depth chart is Scott Tolzien, an undrafted free agent in 2011. Tolzien rates as an average backup. When a concussion sidelined Luck for a week in November, Tolzien started and passed for 205 yards and one touchdown with two interceptions in a 28-7 loss to Pittsburgh.

South Point sports book director Chris Andrews ranks Luck as the NFL’s fourth-best starting quarterback entering the 2017 season. (

“I disagree with him,” Vaccaro said. “Luck is in the top 10, not top five.”

Andrews said the difference in Indianapolis from Luck to Tolzien is seven points, meaning the Colts could be 4-point underdogs at L.A. in Week 1 if Tolzien is the starter. Vaccaro said he would probably make the Rams 2-point favorites with Luck out.

The Rams were an offensive mess last season, finishing 4-12, including 0-7 with rookie Jared Goff as their starting quarterback. Goff passed for five touchdowns with seven interceptions as a starter. Three of his touchdown throws came in a 49-21 loss at New Orleans. Goff was not good, to say the least.

Still, Goff would go off as a favorite in the opener if Tolzien is the Colts’ quarterback.

“Only because it’s the first game of the season, I give the Rams a little more credit,” Vaccaro said. “It’s not the middle of the season when they are 2-8.”

A Quarterback’s Value to the Point Spread
(Numbers provided by Chris Andrews)
Team, Starting QB (Backup), Points
Packers, Aaron Rodgers (Brett Hundley), 8
Colts, Andrew Luck (Scott Tolzien), 7
Lions, Matthew Stafford (Jake Rudock), 7
Steelers, Ben Roethlisberger (Landry Jones), 7
Giants, Eli Manning (Geno Smith), 6.5
Seahawks, Russell Wilson (Trevone Boykin), 6.5
Ravens, Joe Flacco (Ryan Mallett), 6.5
Chiefs, Alex Smith (Tyler Bray), 6
Chargers, Philip Rivers (Kellen Clemens), 6
Raiders, Derek Carr (EJ Manuel), 6

NFL Season Win Totals
Posted at South Point sports book
(Updated July 30; Opening lines from April 30)

New England Patriots
Open: 11 Over -120
Current: 12.5 Under -125
Pittsburgh Steelers
Open: 10.5 Over -120
Current: 10.5 Over -125
Seattle Seahawks
Open: 10.5 over/under -110
Current: 10.5 Over -120
Green Bay Packers
Open: 10 Under -120
Current: 10 over/under -110
Atlanta Falcons
Open: 10 Under -120
Current: 9.5 Over -120
Dallas Cowboys
Open: 9.5 Over -120
Current: 9.5 Over -115
Oakland Raiders
Open: 9.5 Over -120
Current: 9.5 Over -115
Kansas City Chiefs
Open: 9 Over -120
Current: 9 Over -130
Carolina Panthers
Open: 9 Over -120
Current: 9 Over -125
New York Giants
Open: 9 Over -115
Current: 9 over/under -110
Baltimore Ravens
Open: 9.5 Under -125
Current: OFF
Indianapolis Colts
Open: 9 Under -115
Current: OFF
Tennessee Titans
Open: 9.5 Under -120
Current: 8.5 Over -135
Arizona Cardinals
Open: 7.5 over/under -110
Current: 8.5 over/under -110
Minnesota Vikings
Open: 8.5 over/under -110
Current: 8.5 Under -115
Houston Texans
Open: 8.5 Over -120
Current: 8.5 Under -125
Cincinnati Bengals
Open: 8.5 Over -120
Current: 8.5 Under -135
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Open: 8 over/under -110
Current: 8 Over -140
Philadelphia Eagles
Open: 8.5 over/under -110
Current: 8 Over -135
Denver Broncos
Open: 8.5 Over -120
Current: 8 over/under -110
New Orleans Saints
Open: 8.5 Under -120
Current: 8 Under -125
Los Angeles Chargers
Open: 7.5 over/under -110
Current: 7.5 Over -130
Washington Redskins
Open: 7.5 Over -120
Current: 7.5 over/under -110
Detroit Lions
Open: 8 over/under -110
Current: 7.5 Under -120
Miami Dolphins
Open: 7.5 over/under -110
Current: 7.5 Under -135
Buffalo Bills
Open: 6 over/under -110
Current: 7 Under -145
Jacksonville Jaguars
Open: 5.5 Over -120
Current: 6.5 Over -130
Los Angeles Rams
Open: 5.5 Over -120
Current: 5.5 Over -125
Chicago Bears
Open: 5 over/under -110
Current: 5 Over -115
San Francisco 49ers
Open: 4.5 over/under -110
Current: 4.5 Over -150
Cleveland Browns
Open: 4 over/under -110
Current: 4.5 Over -115
New York Jets
Open: 5.5 Over -120
Current: 4 Under -120

back to news

Subscribe to our newsletter

"VSiN City” is the must-have, daily report for serious sports bettors, direct from the gambling capital of the world.


Online Sports Betting Marketplace

Featured Tickets for Sale on

1) Boston Red Sox to Win 2018 World Series - Sale Price: $12,499, Collect: $46,200, Odds: 2.70/1

2) Oakland Athletics to Win 2018 AL West  - Sale Price: $2,350, Collect: $6,100, Odds: +160

3) Javy Baez to Win 2018 National League MVP - Sale Price: $1,150, Collect: $6,100, Odds: 4.30/1

Go to or call

All tickets are open to Bidding. Prices & availability are subject to change.